Home from home

*** Currently blogging at http://www.betternation.org/ ***

Wednesday, April 28, 2010

Bigot-gate

There are a lot of moments during election campaigns that are mistakenly held up as game-changers. The Prime Minister calling a widow and (until very recently) a Labour voter a “bigoted woman” is a bona fide one.



There’s not much else to say about it other than to sit back and watch Labour’s poll figures slide but it’s important to remember that this isn’t a mistake that could happen to just anyone.



For all that Gordon Brown likes to wear his moral compass as a badge of honour; Cameron, Clegg, Salmond, Lucas and even Farage would all have the respect and decency to never make such a regrettable comment, even under their breath.



Brown just finished digging his own political grave in Rochdale. It’s Clegg, Cameron or Miliband from here on in.

Here's a question though, in light of the SNP's unsuccessful legal challenge, can Salmond not just take the now discredited Brown's spot?

More seriously, I do hope the SNP drops the debate grievance. Saying Sky and BBC have got it wrong is one thing, saying the courts have is quite another. It's time to move on and focus on the issues. People will vote on Trident, they won't vote on who was or wasn't on a tv debate.

14 comments:

Mark said...

To be perfectly honest with you, it is a storm in a teacup. The numbers will not fall due to this. It will be forgotten over the weekend and as the pressure mounts in the last couple of days it will surely even out between the three.

Personally, as a person who deals with the public all the time and also welcomes immigration, I will not condemn what Brown has said in private.

I agree with your point in regards to the SNP. I have stood amazed with wide glaring eyes as they have managed to form no cohesive powerful argument. A party that claims to have the Scottish public interest at heart has become obsessed by the third debate. All other issues have been lost in a sea of mist surrounding one debate. It comes across as bad, petty politics, no matter if you agree with the principle or not.

When I conjure up the image of the SNP in Westminster, I struggle to piece together what they actually want. I vaguely remember something about Trident and being friendly with the Welsh.

I would like to know if the SNP support is happy with this assessment. What would you have changed? Do you feel your arguments have been lost in somewhat this election?

Anonymous said...

What the bigot comment does is give people an excuse to move votes. If a party is solid in the polls things like this are not game changers.eg Reagans bomb Russia comment and lots of others besides like Prescott's punch. If however support is soft we can see a big swing. What I will be interested in is where the numbers go, to Lib Dem or Tory in England or Lib Dem and SNP in Scotland. The SNP are a lucky party if you must have bad news have it on a day your main rival has worse. Michael

Dubbieside said...

Jeff

Yesterday Yousuf was calling him "Gordon Brown rock star" today it is Gordon Brown disaSTAR.

What we witnessed here is the real face of Gordon Brown, this was the Nokia thrower, the bully. This is what Labour are trying to hide from the general public.

He did not even have the manners or the "moral compass" to issue a sincere apology, just some rubbish about helping reporters and people reporting his private conversations. If anything that made it even worse.

Is that worth 50 seats to Cameron?

Anonymous said...

Yeah, but was she a bigot though?

Alasdair said...

"For all that Gordon Brown likes to wear his moral compass as a badge of honour; Cameron, Clegg, Salmond, Lucas and even Farage would all have the respect and decency to never make such a regrettable comment, even under their breath."

Really?! Everybody and I mean *everybody* will say something about someone at some-point which is, well, less than complimentary.

If recent scandals have told us anything, it's that politicians and no better than the rest of us and in a lot of cases many times worse.

DougtheDug said...

Saying Sky and BBC have got it wrong is one thing, saying the courts have is quite another.

Well if you read the court judgment the Judge Lady Smith says the BBC have been and will be impartial in their treatment of the SNP. Para [37]

Saying the courts got it right is laughable.

Anonymous said...

Hi Mark. You wanted the view of SNP on your assessment. Well my view as an SNP supporter is your assessment is complete. Hope that's OK.

Allan said...

Anon

No she was not a bigot and the TV reporters backed this up and they heard every question the woman asked Brown.

No doubt the saps in Labour will try and turn this around and discredit the poor woman to save face!Browns face that is.

I hope this is brought up in the last UK leaders debate and Labour plummet even further into the abyss.

Good bye Gordon.

Anonymous said...

That should read complete rubbish.

Anonymous said...

As I watched the farce unfold, I couldn't help think of "In the Thick of it" and who was playing whom.
The "solution" of getting the PM to go to the woman's house and apologise again was pure Malcolm Tucker,but as Brown emerged and explained his actions with that gruesome smile on his face, I could imagine Tucker shouting down his mobile "who the f***k told him to smile"?

Pure dead brilliant!!

Allan said...

Bigot-gate certainly took the shine off the news regarding the SNPs court case today. What a shame!

Observer said...

Yeah, but was she a bigot though?
_______________________________

She could easily be portrayed as a bigot, but then so frankly could my mother in law or any number of older people I know that don't understand the changing demographic of Britain.

He should have answered her question.

And if he thought her a bigot he should not have apologised.

And above all he should NEVER have talked about British jobs for British workers and then taken a hissy fit when confronted with the reality of where comments like that lead to.

Anonymous said...

He had a chance to take a stand and confront bigotry head-on but by apologising he's left himself wide open to criticism.

Her comments could be interpreted as bigoted and saying that there are many others like her doesn't excuse that.

Anonymous said...

I think saying that Eastern Europeans are claiming benefits their not entitled to is quite bigoted.